Use of a New Investigational Interlocking Nail Supplement in the Repair of Comminuted Diaphyseal Tibia Fractures in Two Dogs
Two dogs were diagnosed with highly comminuted diaphyseal tibial fractures following traumatic incidents. Investigational hybrid interlocking nail (ILN) bolt/external skeletal fixator (ESF) pins were used to repair both fractures. The surgery was successful, and fractures healed without complications by 6 weeks (case no. 1) and 17 weeks (case no. 2) after surgery. This article describes the application and the advantages of a new, investigational ILN supplement that was specifically designed to accomplish initial rigid stability and allow progressive destabilization to the fracture repair. The authors are continuing to study the biomechanical properties of this procedure in order to accurately establish clear recommendations for its use in certain fracture situations.
Introduction
Fracture healing is a process of bone regeneration. It is divided into well-documented stages: inflammation, connective tissue and fibrocartilage formation (soft callus), bony bridging or mineralization (hard callus), and remodeling.1 The surgeon’s goal is to create an optimal environment for each stage of fracture healing. The initial goal of fracture fixation is to rigidly stabilize fracture fragments and maintain both length and alignment. Rigid fixation supports fracture healing during the first stage, but after the development of the bridging callus, it may interfere with the normal progression of bone healing. During the remodeling phase, mechanical loading of the bone becomes important, because increasing load stimulates callus remodeling and maturation.1,2 Progressively increasing the weight-bearing forces to accelerate bone healing can be achieved by staged disassembly of the initial fracture repair.
The type of fracture repair technique utilized depends on each fracture situation. It has been proposed that open fracture manipulation should be limited in highly comminuted fractures, in order to minimize the disruption of the soft-tissue envelope and blood supply to the healing bone.1 This type of fracture repair is termed “hands off” or a form of biological fracture treatment.1 Biological fracture treatment attempts to attain a balance between the use of minimal implants (to provide sufficient stability) and the maximal preservation of soft-tissue integrity and vascularity.3
Comminuted diaphyseal fractures are challenging to repair because of their high degree of instability and extensive soft-tissue injury. Of the fracture repair methods available, interlocking nail (ILN) fixation is especially suited to repairing comminuted fractures, because ILNs resist bending, axial, and torsional forces and can be used as a biological fracture treatment.4–7 Fracture repair failures from breakage or bending of the ILN or the screws, and from the ILN pulling away from intact bone, may occur if the repair is insufficiently stable during the initial period of bone healing. The ILN should maximally fill the medullary canal at the fracture site to avoid strain at the nail/bone and screw or bolt/bone interfaces.6 Maximal filling of the medullary canal is not always possible because of the limited number of ILN diameters available and because of the geometry of bones. Because fracture repairs are sometimes deemed insufficiently stable at the time of surgery with ILN alone, ILN supplemental procedures such as stack pins, external skeletal fixator (ESF) pins, and double ILN have been developed.8,9 The purpose of this report is to discuss a new ILN fracture repair technique that was applied to comminuted tibial fractures in two dogs.
Case Reports
Case No. 1
A 5-month-old, 10-kg, castrated male, cocker spaniel cross was referred for treatment of a closed, comminuted, mid-diaphyseal fracture of the left tibia. The fracture had occurred 3 days previously as a result of a motor vehicle accident. On physical examination, the dog was nonweight bearing in the left hind limb. Substantial soft-tissue swelling was noted in the tibial area. Mediolateral and craniocaudal radiographic views of the left tibia were obtained [Figures 1A, 1B]. A comminuted, closed, diaphyseal fracture was identified, with a caudomedially displaced comminuted fragment.
The dog was premedicated with atropinea (0.04 mg/kg intramuscularly [IM]), acepromazineb (0.03 mg/kg IM), and butorphanolc (0.3 mg/kg IM). General anesthesia was induced with a combination of ketamined (5.5 mg/kg intravenously [IV]) and diazepame (0.5 mg/kg IV) and was maintained with isoflurane in oxygen. Cefazolin sodium phosphatef (22 mg/kg IV q 2 hours) was given at the time of induction.
The left rear limb was prepared for aseptic surgery, and a medial parapatellar incision was made. The tibial plateau was drilled with a 3.5-mm drill bit, allowing for the introduction of a 4-mm diameter, 101-mm long, 02–02 model 11 ILN.g
The proper length of the ILN was chosen by measuring it against the radiographs of the intact, left tibia. A tibial extensionh was attached to the selected ILN to assist nor-mograde insertion of the nail distally.
A limited surgical approach was then made over the fracture site, and the ILN was directed into the distal fracture fragment, incorporating the comminuted piece under direct visualization. Once the ILN was seated, the ILN jigi was attached to the tibial extension, and stab incisions were made on the skin over the ILN holes at the medial aspect of the limb, under the guidance of the jig. Through these stab incisions, 1.5-mm holes were made with a 1.5-mm drill bit in the proximal and the distal fracture fragments using the appropriate holes in the jig. The jig was removed, and the holes were over-drilled with a 2.0-mm drill bit to accept the hybrid ILN bolt/ESF pins. Next, the holes were measured. Four, 2.5-mm external diameter, 2-mm “bolt diameter,” hybrid ILN bolt/ESF pinsj were cut to the desired length to engage both cortices with the threaded part of the pin. The pins were placed using a Jacob’s chuck. Finally, the tibial extension was detached. The surgical site was lavaged, and the repair was examined for stability. All surgical incisions were closed in a routine manner.
The hybrid ILN bolt/ESF pins were connected using medium SK clampsk and a connecting bar, creating a type I ESF construct. A sterile bandage was applied over the ESF, and the entire leg was placed in a soft-padded bandage because of distal limb swelling. Postoperative radiographs documented acceptable alignment and proper implant location [Figures 2A, 2B]. The owner was advised to limit exercise to leash walking for the first 4 weeks and then to increase exercise gradually. The ESF bandage was kept clean and changed every second day for 2 weeks on an out-patient basis. The skin-pin interfaces were cleaned and covered with sterile antibiotic ointment at each bandage change. After the suture removal at 14 days, the bandage over the ESF was changed every second week or as necessary.
Six-week follow-up radiographs taken under general anesthesia documented bony callus that bridged the fracture gap on both radiographic views. The ESF hybrid pins were removed, leaving the ILN in the medullary canal [Figures 3A, 3B]. No further bandaging was necessary. Ten weeks postoperatively, the dog had a normal gait.
Case No. 2
A 9-year-old, 23-kg, intact male Australian cattle dog was presented for evaluation of a highly comminuted left tibial fracture and a right inguinal laceration, sustained after motor vehicular trauma. On physical examination, the dog was non-ambulatory in the left rear limb. Radiographs documented a closed, highly comminuted fracture of the proximal one-third of the left tibia [Figures 4A, 4B].
The animal’s anesthesia and perioperative protocol was identical to case no. 1. A limited medial parapatellar was performed to approach the proximal left tibia. The tibial plateau was predrilled with a 3.5-mm drill bit in order to facilitate the ILN insertion into the bone. Next, the medullary cavity was opened and prepared for ILN placement with a 6-mm reamer.l A tibial extension was attached to a 6-mm diameter, 140-mm long, 02–02 model 11 ILN. The ILN was inserted and directed in a normograde fashion into the distal fragment. The tibia was predrilled through stab incisions over the ILN holes in a medial to lateral direction with a 2.0-mm drill bit, using the ILN jig as a guide. The ILN jig was removed, and the holes were over-drilled with a 2.7-mm drill bit and measured for the hybrid ILN bolt/ESF pin placement. Four, 3.2-mm external diameter, 2.7-mm “bolt diameter,” hybrid ILN bolt/ESF pins were cut to the desired length and inserted with a Jacob’s chuck. The tibial extension was removed. Through a stab incision, an 18-gauge, full-cerclage wire was placed in order to secure the butterfly fragment. The surgical site was lavaged and closed in a routine fashion.
The hybrid ILN bolt/ESF pins were secured to a connecting bar medially using medium SK clamps, creating a type I ESF supplement. The limb was placed in a soft-padded bandage. The inguinal laceration was debrided and primarily sutured. Postoperative radiographs documented satisfactory alignment and proper implant placement [Figures 5A, 5B]. The owner was advised to limit exercise for 4 weeks and then increase exercise gradually. Bandage care was identical to that described for case no. 1.
Radiographs taken at 7 weeks postoperatively showed maturing callus. At a 12-week follow-up, radiographs suggested establishment of a bony bridge. The ESF connecting bar with the SK clamps were removed, and all four hybrid ILN bolt/ESF pins were cut below the skin under general anesthesia, leaving the ILN locked [Figures 6A, 6B]. The tool was now functioning as a regular ILN (without any supplementation) in order to decrease the stability of the repair and increase the loading forces on the weight-bearing limb. No further bandages were applied.
Recheck radiographs at 17 weeks were consistent with a healed fracture, and the dog was using the limb normally. The hybrid ILN bolts were removed under general anesthesia for further destabilization of the repair. The ILN was left in the medullary canal [Figures 7A, 7B]. At last contact with the owner (i.e., 9 months postoperatively), no repair complications were reported.
Discussion
The hybrid ILN bolt/ESF pins described in this report allowed the ILN to be tied in to a type I ESF, which offered a new option for ILN supplementation. This supplemental procedure was specifically designed to provide rigid initial stability and facilitate progressive destabilization of the repair in a minimally invasive fashion. The hybrid pins are manufactured from 316L stainless steel with a standard pin diameter to fit the ESF clamps, and they have a positive profile cis-cortex self-tapping thread to engage the bone. They are available in three diameters to suit all of the ILNs produced by Innovative Animal Products [Table 1].10
The hybrid ILN bolt/ESF pins lock the ILN to the bone, and they mechanically connect each main fracture fragment through the ESF. Clinically, any instability noted at the time of surgery, from movement between the screw-bolt and the ILN, has been eliminated with this supplemental technique. Another advantage of this procedure is that it allows progressive destabilization of the fracture repair by staged disassembly of the supplemental device, to increase the load on the healing bone and thus stimulate callus maturation. Disassembly of the supplement is via a noninvasive, minor surgical procedure that is coordinated with the fracture healing. Multiple options for staged disassembly are possible [Table 2].
To date, osteomyelitis has not been a problem with this procedure. An additional requirement when using the technique is added bandaging to protect the ESF. Also, increased owner compliance and good home care are important factors to ensure a successful outcome.
Conclusion
A new, investigational supplementation option for ILN repair was utilized in the treatment of highly comminuted diaphyseal tibial fractures in two dogs. Because the ILN had to function in a nonload-shearing or buttress mode, the hybrid ILN bolt/ESF pins were utilized. No complications occurred during the postoperative period, and both fractures healed after staged disassembly of the supplemental device. The hybrid ILN bolt/ESF pins offered initial rigid stability and the ability for staged, noninvasive destabilization, allowing progressive loading of the maturating bony callus. Further studies are planned to test the biomechanical properties of these hybrid ILN bolt/ESF pins and to verify the demand for this ILN supplemental procedure in certain fracture situations.
Atropine sulfate injection; Phoenix Scientific, Inc., St. Joseph, MO 64506
Acepromazine; Boehringer Ingelheim Vetmedica, Inc., St. Joseph, MO 64506
Torbugesic-SA; Fort Dodge Animal Health, Fort Dodge, IA 50501
KetaVed; Phoenix Scientific, Inc., St. Joseph, MO 64506
Diazepam injection, UPS; Abbott Laboratories, North Chicago, IL 60064
Cefazolin for injection, UPS; Randbaxy Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Jacksonville, FL 32216
Interlocking nail; Innovative Animal Products, Rochester, MN 55091
Tibia extension; Innovative Animal Products, Rochester, MN 55901
Interlocking nail jig; Innovative Animal Products, Rochester, MN 55901
Interlocking nail hybrid pin; IMEX, Longview, TX 75603
SK clamp; IMEX, Longview, TX 75603
Reamer for ILN; Innovative Animal Products, Rochester, MN 55901












Citation: Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association 41, 3; 10.5326/0410203












Citation: Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association 41, 3; 10.5326/0410203












Citation: Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association 41, 3; 10.5326/0410203












Citation: Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association 41, 3; 10.5326/0410203












Citation: Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association 41, 3; 10.5326/0410203












Citation: Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association 41, 3; 10.5326/0410203












Citation: Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association 41, 3; 10.5326/0410203

Lateral (1A) and craniocaudal (1B) radiographic views of the left tibial fracture in a 5-month-old cocker spaniel (case no. 1).

Preoperative lateral (4A) and craniocaudal (4B) radiographic views of the left tibial facture in a 9-year-old Australian cattle dog (case no. 2).


